Bill Marx wrote me an e-mail about my Moomtaj posting. He rightly pointed out that my barb regarding his review of Moomtaj was off base in that it didn't reference anything he really wrote in his actual review.
My main point of the posting was to look at how the three critics addressed the riskiness of the New Rep. The barbs at the contents of the reviews were more of blogger's license.
In Marx's case I actually was more trying to caricature highbrow ideology, but his criticism is fair. I guess my humor needs work.